489 pie your breasts

490 to the face

491, back of your legs

492 pie your pussy

493 to the chest

494 half a sandwich

495 - finish the pie Sandwich

496 pie your pussy

497, face again

498 arm

499 pie face

500!!!!

Big pie to the face

501 in the face, up, over and rubbed in the hair

502 pie your pussy

503, boobs

504 start the first sandwich of the 500s

505! Other side of the sandwich

I will also like to offer Frodo the chance out since we hit the 500 milestone. I'm willing to shorten the week deadline down BUT ONLY IF we all get to decide one final task to be done at the end of the pies. How do you feel about that Frodobean?

Omg YES!!
Please. Be kind tho

Or don't I think something this epic should end with a savoury trashing

Sod off.
Whatever happens to me comes back to you twice as bad. Do you want more Gravy??

This is revenge of the forums so should we let the forums decide?

They can decide.
But if you sway the vote then I'm coming after you with double the amount.

The people shall decide! Everyone post your ideas below and we can discuss what's the best idea. I'm ecstatic to see what devious dares we can come up with.

I like the idea of savoury so I'm going to say a big bucket of condiments (ketchup, mustard, mayo, BBQ and relish) to be taken over the head to crown this challenge off.

Well love big cake to face as got me good last year own back on hear

I am thinking a nice big bucket of guacamole because you love green

I've got 5 cakes anyway

I think a nice big bucket of mixed savoury food to dunk your head full in

yea that another good idea or maybe a bucket of mixed up sweet stuff

Why not both, dunk in each one alternately then both poured over the head that's my vote

Glad to see this continued to reach epic heights while I was away!
The 500+ mark is quite something.