So, I decided to make a list of my favourite all time wam vids. It was surprisingly easy, so I started to wonder exactly what it was about these particular films that kept me coming back to them, despite having seen 100's over quite a few years. I realised that they all had several specific elements in common that when combined made the film, for me, a 'classic'.
The list went something like this:

At the Messy Movies - Messy Fun
Pie Wedgies - Messy Fun
The Quiz Show (Lexi and Liz) - Messy Girl
The Recertification Process - Lenny
What's My Fetish? - TZ
The Really Nasty Gameshow (Ep 1) - Bound2bMessy
Heather vs Paris - PieFightGirls
Musical Chairs - Messy Dreams
Red Curtain Sessions - Pied Pinups

Like I said, I have really liked many, many films, but the ones that came straight to mind all a combination of:

Nudity
Plot or some other dramatic/structure element, eg a gameshow
Multiple Girls

I hadn't realised that I was so specific! I knew I liked certain stuff, but it was this very specific combination that surprised me. So I got to wondering two things:

1. Are the rest of you like this - what combination do you (unconsciously) seek out and return to?
2. Can you recommend any more that would suit me?

You're tastes and mine sound quite similar when you put it like that. Therefore nearly everything on www.messymayhem.com should tick the three boxes you have given

Pretty much, all the customs I pay for have those three elements.

Check out Cream Covered Catfight and Famous People Pie Fight.

They are customs of mine.


http://cali_logans_wam_zone.umd.net/downloads/all

I'd put a lot of the same movies on my all-time favorites list, for much the same reasons.

Nudity is great, but I like to see some clothing destruction/messiness before the stripping starts. I completely agree about having a structure, or at least an element of performance: I enjoy it if the model is either putting on a show, or knows they're being watched.

I also prefer multiple girls unless it's a single girl interacting with an offscreen character (like Messygirl's clown videos) or talking directly to the viewer. Solo wallowing doesn't really do it for me unless the model is talking to the camera or otherwise very lively (as much as it pains me to say it, some of Rob Blaine's solo scenes could become very tedious as they went on SO long).

And since you asked for recommendations, another one that fits your criteria is "Custard Queens" starring Kate and Hannah from GlamourGunge:

http://glamourgunge.umd.net/download_info/custard_queens_2

Everything I've gotten from GlamourGunge has been good, for that matter.