From my recent experiences, I would recommend the following...
Molasses Condensed milk Clear karo syrup
I'm also really into chocolate sauce, mayo and puddings... you can look at my profiles and my videos and see the results. The last 5 clips are my messiest session to date and if you're into wam, you'll like the way it all feels
If someone wanted to construct a tank to hold mud for satisfying that sinking feeling, what clay product would best to use? I don't want to use something i dug up from the yard but a product that can be purchased and mixed.