Cadence is in charge of organizing a gala for her boss, Dixie, in honor of some family heirlooms that have recently come into Dixie's possession. Dixie warns Cadence that everything needs to be perfect. Cadence has made some mistakes in the past but this time there's no room for error or it could mean her job. She also alerts her of one potential problem, her twin sister Trixie wants the heirlooms for herself and may try to make trouble. Cadence swears that she will do everything to make sure nothing happens. At the event, everything is going perfectly as Cadence gives a speech welcoming the guests. As she waits for Dixie to arrive, she sticks close to the table where the heirlooms are displayed, surrounded by all of the pies that will be a treat for the guests later, to make sure they are safe. Suddenly, Trixie appears and tries to take the heirlooms but Cadence catches her in the act and tells her that she has to leave. Trixie isn't going to go away that easily, though, and she prepares to fight Cadence. That isn't the sort of thing Cadence was expecting and is caught off guard and humiliated as Trixie grabs her and slaps her face. Not stopping there, Trixie rips at Cadence's clothes, tearing her dress open and ripping it off her. Cadence is exposed and embarrassed and realizes that she has to fight back. She takes a swing and manages to knock Trixie completely onto the floor. While Trixie is out of it, Cadence hides the heirlooms. She's feeling pretty smug about herself, even though she's naked at a gala event, when Trixie comes to and demands to know where they are. Cadence refuses to tell her so Trixie grabs one of the pies and smushes it in her face. Cadence is mortified but refuses to tell Trixie where the heirlooms are. So Trixie continues to pie her in the face until she's completely caked with pie. Finally Trixie realizes that the pieing isn't going to convince Cadence so she changes tactics, pinching her nipples painfully until she relents and tells her where to find them.
Later, Cadence is still naked and pie covered, trying to figure out what to tell Dixie when she arrives. As Dixie enters and sees her, she demands to know what happened. When Cadence apologizes and tells her what Trixie did to her, Dixie angrily pies her in the face. Cadence is in disbelief that her boss would resort to the same punishment as her evil twin sister but as she tries to reason with her and apologize, Dixie just continues to pie her in the face. Finally, Cadence has had enough and snaps. She tells Dixie she can take her job and shove it as she grabs her dress and rips her clothes off, just as Trixie did to her, so she can share in her humiliation. Not stopping there, Cadence grabs a pie and slams it in Dixie's face, so she can taste her own medicine. Now it's on as Dixie and Cadence, both pied, naked and humiliated cat and pie fight until all the pie is gone. Cadence exits in a huff, leaving Dixie standing stickily in the middle of her ruined gala.