Two videos, to kinds of pie hits -- try and ignore the differences in the silly reactions (particularly the first woman), camera or after shot, if you're able just focus on the hits themselves.
What I'm driving at: The first girl - beautiful, pied very well and doesn't wipe at all.
Second girl - beautiful, pied very well (twice even) but wipes away immediately.
Not to try and sway opinion, but beyond the slight lack of after math, the divisive outfit or the faux-tantrum, I 100% much much more prefer a pie hit like hers, where she's ruined but isn't an unrecognizable blob of cream and doesn't immediately wipe away the pie hit itself.