We wanted to get some feedback on our pie booth shoots. We usually use about 25 pies per girl. Would anymore be overkill?

I would say there's like a diminishing utility to adding more of the same thing.
Like pie number 26 would just be pieing the back of another pie. Maybe if they changed color every few or something so there's variety.

25... for her left side. 25 for her right side.

Agree with the diminishing utility of going beyond 25. 25 creamy pies, with good delivery and coverage are key.

I love your Pie Booth scenes so much that they inspired me to create a pie target board, which I would have improved with additional bondage (perhaps of hands and legs to show the feet?). I tried this out in a session with Kate - though unfortunately my cameras weren't set up properly to capture it and share the results.

I really like the situational comedy of the pie booth...

e.g. Somebody is tricked into being the target, or has to be because of a bet.
The target thinks they will be in there for only a pie or two but have to stay locked up and a huge audience passes by before the end of their shift.
A devious masters of ceremonies decides to lower the price per pie or insists to the target that they have to throw from behind a line, but then lets people just walk up and smash the pie in their face.

Cranking up the number could add to that.

I'm more of someone who needs variety of pie hits. However I've enjoyed all the Pie Booth scenes I've seen due to the hard thrown nature of the pies used. I'd be happy with more pies.

For me I don't find there much point adding more pies once a girl is completely covered. Maybe if there is some wiping off of the pies in the middle then a higher number can work.

I also think an alternate forfeit should be available to anyone who wishes to avoid the pie booth.

I do welcome the pie booth shoots because of the vigour with which the pies are thrown and the consequent impact of the pies

It's also true that sometimes less is more, and this principle is often confirmed by WAM videos where the model simply disappears under the mess

However, I reckon that the models chosen to be subjected to the humiliation of being pelted with pies in the pie booth could certainly take a few more in their faces, and so in the poll I have opted for the compromise of 75 pies as a kind of generous midpoint between 25 and 100.

Go on, throw a few more! You know it makes sense

I think there's only a point to using more pies than this if the victim gets slimed as well and the pie coverage needs replacing. Which in a pie booth isn't the most practical situation.

I agree with the "diminishing returns" idea in theory, and I think different colored pies are a good way to counter that... But equally I think adding more pies when coverage is already good does add to the humiliation factor.

It's like you've proved your point - you've already clobbered the girl - but they still have to comtinue to sit there and get pelted again and again. Sounds good to me!

25 is fine. My other 2 cents: You should interweave the front and side angles throughout the scene (like you used to in your older videos) instead of just having the side wide angle at the end.

I agree with the 'diminishing returns' theory. Unless you are specifically trying to break a record the extra expense and time is pointless. This seems to follow through in principle with every WAM substance excess. This is invariably observed by producers and wammers alike. How much more covered with one thing can anyone get than 100 percent? How much more submerged can anyone get than 'entirely'?

There really have to be some surprises and variety throughout in order to maintain interest.

However many it takes to get to this!

Precisely!

Are we talking specifically about the Bikini Pie Booth skits? If so, I'd have to say that more than 20-odd pies would only work for me if it's written into the skit somehow. More people show up, people pay extra to throw multiple pies at once, there's a rapid wipe-off/pie/wipe-off/pie exchange, things like that. I'm all for more mess in general, but if it's just pie after pie after pie, idk what the value add would be...feels like we'd hit a point of diminishing returns. Just my humble opinion. Carry on.

I've always subscribed to the "more is better" philosophy.
I met a stoner once who said, "You can't appreciate moderation until you've appreciated excess."

I hope this means we're due for some more of these shoots soon. They are among my favorite!

i find it mad that people wanna stick to 25 and its a close runner up to 100 pies lol. it boggles my mind thinking people wont wanna seee that mayhem

From a purely personal point of view I never tire of seeing very attractive ladies getting pied repeatedly, again and again getting those wonderful MG pies smushed into pretty faces is a utopian like Nirvana for me. So yes I'm a 100 club member

I'd say it's important to vary the colors and textures of the pies every few pies... that helps avoid the "pieing the pie" problem and helps reduce the "diminishing returns" issue

Thanks to everyone who voted in our poll. Looks like 100 pies is something you want to see, but 25 pies was a close second. So since we are celebrating 25 years of Messygirl, we will incorporate 25 pies in many of our shoots. I'm sure a couple of 100 pie shoots could be a possibility in 2022. Not sure if any one girl on video has ever been hit with 100 thrown pies? Does anyone know?

Didn't pie girl Kay do more than 100 plus some slime?? Damn I miss her