Well, I suggested it in another post, so why not? I'll get things rolling:

Ariel's Pie Shop
Shaun and Tiffany's pie fight from MFV14
Julie's Double Ecstasy
Lovinia in Bed

Pretty much the entire Phoebe Rodriguez catalog, in my opinion. Also Pie Line, hot Fudge Sundae Afternoon, and Pie Lovers from PieVids have long been favorites.

Pie Fight Girls stuff has weathered well and bears unlimited viewings: Heather Vs Paris for example but many, many more.

At the Messy Movies is still great: Nice creamy mess and very cute girls given something to do whilst slopping the pies all over each other.

Those Julie and Lovinia scenes are HOT. Anyone know if they are still available?

I love that Redd and Trisha scene from pievids in the kitchen.

lovinia is my ex wife. i still have all of that material. in fact, i've re-edited all of that stuff and got it to come out in much better quality. i don't have any of it for sale at the moment, but i can ask if she would mind me selling her stuff again. i don't think she'd mind.

Most producers have a few scenes that just connected with me and still do. In terms of an overall catalog I'd say WLP which did such a good job of capturing the silly sexiness of girl next door types plus benefits from ending on a hgh note rather than churning out the same old same old and going through the motions. And oh that Chele........