One of the great things about a two girl shoot is that when the first girl gets trashed the second clean girl has an inkling about what is going to happen to her.

What is everyone's favourite second clean girl's reaction to the trashing of the first. Do you like it when the dawning realisation of getting annihilated hits her?

For me nothing beats Taylor's expression as Nicole gets pied in The Easy Modeling Gig 2 from Messygirl!

Ellie from The Man and The Wife. That girl has natural comic timing.

Slapstick Stuff has some awesome videos that contain this kind of scenario. One reason I usually only buy two girl scenes or do customs of 2 girl scenes.

Yes, absolutely love this. It's one of my favorite things to look for in a scene. I'll have to go back and find some examples of some of my favorites.

Especially when the first person gets slimed or pied over and over. The juxtaposition between the ever increasingly messy subject and the clean one, who is awaiting their fate is such a fun sight.

It also makes me as the viewer want to see the clean person get messy, more and more. It's a tease the longer the scene goes on while the second person stays clean. I'm sure it's a tease for them as well, knowing they will be getting their messy turn eventually.

Everything MajorMoose just said is why coed WAM is my all-time favorite. There's the immediate ability to put myself in both parties' shoes, from the shock and secret enjoyment of seeing the other person messed up to the realization that your own likelihood of staying clean isn't looking good.

Oh god yes! One of my favorite types of mainstream clip is a line of people getting pied one by one with the anticipation growing bit by bit. If you like this, you might like some of the fiction I have on my profile.

An underrated feature of these scenarios is the aftermath. I love watching pied women looking at each other and giggling, maybe scooping a little off and eating it, and in general staying messy for a little while as we wait for everyone to be be pied.

You gotta love the eager anticipation!

It's not the full scene but I've always loved the Messygirl Vegas Pie Booth with Amy and Vika. I wanna say it was Vika that got pied first then both of them got it but Amy, while she was clean and Vika was the messy one, had exceptional expressions.

Haha, thanks so much! Most of our two-girl combos know each other well (some have been friends for YEARS) so I never have to coach much of a reaction out of them.

Probably recency bias, but my favorite one from the last year or two was a VERY precise 4-second window in SS289.... when Ivy sees Willa get clobbered with a cake, laughs hysterically at her, then has a split moment of panic right before she ALSO gets smashed with a cake. The screen grabs don't get the "moment of panic" but if you bought the clip, you know what I mean.

This sort of thing is extra iconic when the girl who is witnessing their scene partner's condition has never been slimed or pied before. Truly fascinating to see someone confronted with their fate before it happens.

This is a great observation, and certainly something I enjoy in a scene.

The look of trepidation on the face of the 'clean' girl when she sees the model next to her get completely trashed with multiple pies and a bucket of gunge or two is fantastic and really adds to a scene for me. It's gives a real sense of 'oh god, all of that mess is heading my way shortly!'

Anticipation is key for me

Some of the best parts are watching people's reactions prior to and right as something happens. That is priceless!

Agreed, anticipation is very important, as well as the (brief) triumph of getting one over your friends until it's your turn. Rob Blaine was great at capturing that Three Stooges/Laurel and Hardy "now you've done it!" dynamic. More recently, in "Ruby's First Time" from The Man and the Wife, Ruby has some great expressions like she just can't believe it.

Right there with you. The other girl watching the other one getting slimed knowing she's next is great, especially if it's a first timer.

There are so many ways the 'second girl' can react as the realisation dawns that it is her turn next. Excited anticipation, trepidation, .... but the one I like is reluctant willingness.

But, as so many others have said, it is all about anticipation.

Loving the screencaps folks! Please keep them coming.

Here are a few more from our shoots.

The name of each video in the order of each pic.

"I Have a Bad Feeling About This" Catalog Number tws-75-0917
"Bella and Calisa" Catalog Number tws-75-1116
"The Spoiled Brat and Her Mom" Catalog Number tws-75-1197
"Dessert is on Me and You" Catalog Number tws-75-1289
"Dinner Party Pie Fight" Catalog Number tws-75-1061
"The Easy Modeling Gig 3" Catalog Number tws-75-0830
"The Carnival Job 5" Catalog Number tws-75-0945
"Talking Shop" Catalog Number tws-75-1204
"The Slop Sisters" Catalog Number tws-75-1208
"Don't Order the Special 4" Catalog Number tws-75-1332
"Don't Order the Special 3" Catalog Number tws-75-1237
"Don't Order the Special 2" Catalog Number tws-75-1058

Absolutely! Those are my favorite too!

Is it possible for you to tell us the titles from each of those photos? It would be greatly appreciated!

Yes, can do.

Just as a side note to this, I feel like the only thing better than "oh god! It's me next!" in a multi-girl scene is when the other girl stays clean because she's won a gameshow or quiz etc.

Therefore the 'clean' girl is ecstatic and gleeful that all of those pies and buckets of gunge are not coming her way! Instead, she gets to revel in dishing out the mess to the loser

Even better when they promise then end up messing her up anyways. That is always an epic response!

This, completely. Maybe it's a writer thing

Yes reluctant willingness is the best imo