Season 38 (!), Episode 08 - annoying but kinda hot Johnny Bananas gets a cake in the face for his 40th birthday.

He was pied last year too (around 15:40). It was a game of "Pie Face," but he gets hit with an actual, face covering pie at the end.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcdzAo-jKqY&t=940s

Oh nice!

Most of the guys on The Challenge need the same.