It looks like I'm finally able to have a messy session soon and while I've got the main ideas I'm always looking for more ways to get messy and be humiliated so I thought I'd see if the community had any suggestions! Imagine this...

With his hair slicked back and dressed in plaid shorts, a white button up, suspenders, a bowtie, and his trusty pair of nerd glasses, this nerd takes the hot seat! First he takes a pie to the face, followed by an atomic wedgie with custard poured down them as well! That's followed by a bucket of green gunge to truly humiliate him!

For now this is all I've got planned but open to mostly any sweet messes or humiliation. I'm shooting the scene in a small inflatable pool and mostly get my messy supplies from Amazon so keep that in mind for any ideas and suggestions! Feel free to post your ideas directly here or send them to me and hope y'all really bully and humiliate this nerd

If you're going through Amazon for supplies you can get gallons of pudding pretty cheap

Sam's club has some butter cream that makes great pies when defrosted

Amazon also has Bavarian cream in large quantities which feels amazing

Making him have to put his feet up on the edge of the pool, take off his shoes and socks and get pies smashed into his bare soles would be pretty humiliating (and awesome haha)

Haha, great idea!
Give this nerd a slick back hair do with peanut butter, perhaps before it becomes slimy, or even before the pie in his face. So we can see his dumb face expression. After pouring the slime all over him, massage it into his pb hair. Turn his hair into a gooey mohawk then to humiliate him even more.

You definitely need something in those pits. Maybe some cake frosting or peanut butter. Also a nice big bottle of caramel over the head would be a great humiliating thing for a nerd to experience.

And after you get humiliated by all these amazing ideas, to bully him even more pour flour all over you and massage it all over your body, hair, arm pits, feet, etc to make all this amazing mess more creamy.

Just promise you'll take off the glasses before the first (I hope there are many more to follow) pie hit. Just to ensure full facial coverage and maximum humiliation. Would also love to see your head dunked in a bucket of thick gunge before you get it poured over your head