Me and the girl friend want to play in gunge so I was gonna order some from messy supplies but I need help choosing what kind to get. She likes thick squishy stuff not runny. Not sure if that's just the way you mix it or are there certain types better for this. We plan on using it in our bath if it's safe for the drain. Let me know! Thanks!

If you go for the extra thick MS gunge and mix it as per the instructions, I find that satisfyingly thick. Also drains without difficulty if you add some extra water when you're done.

I've had great luck with their UV slime. It's a great thick consistency but not so thick it won't flow