List your all-time top 5 models by MistaOveralls

Mine is pretty nostalgic!

1. Naomi K
2. Liz Ashley
3. Lottie Lalay
4. Roxy Mendez
5. Gilly Sampson

Share yours!!

Constantly horny

2/3/252/3/25

Pieman ✓

Southeastern USA

Hard to pick because there's so many great ones, but if I HAVE to pick..

1. Chloe Toy
2. Naomi K
3. Jayce
4. Lottie Lalay
5. Kacie James

2/3/252/3/25

formerly_frank

Toronto

In no particular order:

Payton and Tori from MessyGirl
Jayce
That gorgeous Latina girl from Messyfun who only did one mud pit scene, but I'm blanking on her name.
Shauna from Slapstickstuff

2/3/252/3/25

deadpool

formerly_frank said: In no particular order:

Payton and Tori from MessyGirl
Jayce
That gorgeous Latina girl from Messyfun who only did one mud pit scene, but I'm blanking on her name.
Shauna from Slapstickstuff

Billie (the hot Latina from Messy Fun)

I even wanna be me! -- Zoe

2/3/252/3/25

deadpool

Kym (from Pie Fight Girls, Wet and Messy, and MPV)

London (from Anglefan and Messy Girl)

Lane (from Messy Girl)

Penelope (from Messy Girl)

Jayce

(the ladies from The Man and the Wife aren't models per se, so I couldn't include them; they're real life wives/gfs, so they shouldn't technically count)

I even wanna be me! -- Zoe

2/3/252/3/25

thirdman

Very tough. In no order

Ivy rainn
April paisley
Creammeagain
Kaydens
Luna from rev slymford

2/3/252/3/25

wamguy65

I have to post 6...

MessyGirl Amy
Candleboxxx
Nicole
Jayce
Danielle Maye
Fi Stevens

2/3/252/3/25

MatheusBH29 ✓

Brazil

Nicole (Pievids)
Penelope
Zoey
Blondie (PFG)
Breana

Life is boring without a pie in the face

2/4/252/4/25

Nollvane

Kansas

Gallery Posts Blogs

In (something like) chronological order:

Samantha/Sammy-Jane
Carolyn (MessyFun)
Candy Custard
Messygirl Kim
Messygirl Amy

Love can really mess you up.

2/4/252/4/25

thefdt9

1. Fi Stevens
2. Gilly Sampson
3. Sticky Tara
4. Toy from ministry of mess
5. Von (think she only did a couple of vids but stunning)

2/4/252/4/25

Tizzle

Ariel
Christine - Wetlook U
Tyra - Wetlook Online
Nadya - Wetlooker
Eileen - Wanderland

2/4/252/4/25

briff1es

In no particular order, quite a few not mentioned yet:

Rachel Stevens (Splosh)
Hannah Lewis (B2BM, MessyAngel, Glamourgunge)
Raven (Messygirl)
Nikki (Rev Slymsford/Messymayhem)
Candle Boxx

2/4/252/4/25

madmalc

My top 5 (all UK based)

1 Lottielalay
2. Satine Spark
3. Bri bsmessybakery
4. Ivy Rain
5. Sammy Jane (splosh)

2/4/252/4/25

MistaOveralls

thank you for your responses so far - many names and sites I've not seen for years. A good mix of present and past names too!

Constantly horny

2/4/252/4/25

JazzTalker

Ask me for my top 5 and I'll give you my top 15, but off the cuff and forced to commit a spontaneous list:

1. Toshia (Slapstickstuff)
2. Lyndsay (Slapstickstuff)
3. Crystal (Slapstickstuff)
4. Nikki (Slapstickstuff)
5. Lily (PiedPinups)

Other favorites:
- Melody (The Man and the Wife)
- Courtney (The Man and the Wife)
- Willa (WillaWam, PiedPinups, Messy girl, Slapstickstuff)
- Brin (Slapstickstuff)
- Kasie (Slapstickstuff)
- Brooke (Anglefan)
- Taylor (Slapstickstuff)
- Jennifer (Slapstickstuff)
- Vlada (PieZone, Archnemesis)
- Lila (PieZone)

2/4/252/4/25

goodtimes

Naomi k -Angel video

Liz Ashley-submerged Liz and Ashley

Michelle from most wam- egg custom

Jess from most wam-egg custom

Alice most wam-gooper market

2/4/252/4/25

chris_gee

Jayce and Jilly - Jayce is my go to girl for customs, and Jilly was just as wonderful, and great fun to interact with.

Penelope from Messygirl - The most beautiful woman in WAM.

Star from MPV - Seen in her non WAM stuff too and she's always amazing in everything she does.

Jamie from Gungegirls - The bikini/custard video she did was the first one I ever watched that really did tick every box for me and will always be a sentimental favourite.

2/4/252/4/25

AMWorigins

Michigan

No particular order here

OG Messygirl
Jayce
London Andrews
Lexi
Liz

2/4/252/4/25

Gunge1050

Emily (Hotwam) / Jezebel (Candy Custard)
Harley G
Erin Moore
Scarlett (Slimed Models)
Camille (Wetlook)

2/4/252/4/25

charlie custard ✓

Somerset

Videos Gallery Posts

1. Clown Julie
2. Gilly Sampson
3. Pie Girl Kay
4. Jayce
5. Candy Custard

2/4/252/4/25

splat182002

Borehamwood, Uk

All from Messygirl.

Lexi
Lexi
Lexi
Lexi and
Lexi

I want to get muddy and messy

2/4/252/4/25

messydice

Midlands, UK

Zoey
Lotti Rose
Harley G
Cassandra (Messygirl)
Queenie (Piezone)

2/4/252/4/25

BigPerm

My favorite 5 are,
1. Kordelia Devonshire
2. Messygirl Dakota
3. Lexi
4. Jordan Kingsley
5. Messygirl Kitty

2/4/252/4/25

maxandstar

Videos Gallery Posts

This is an easy one
Star
MG Linda
MG Lucy
The Wife
Jilly

2/5/252/5/25

MrBump

South Yorkshire

1. Lisamoomin (mostwam)
2. StickyTara
3. Gilly Sampson
4. Jess West
5. Cassie (mostwam)

2/5/252/5/25

Tizzle

Never forget.

2/5/252/5/25

SnakeEyes ✓

USA

Antonia - hotwamhd
Sky - mostwam
Lexi - messygirl
Cassie Laine - chocolate overload. I think it's on wamclub
Amber - pie-zone

2/5/252/5/25

osbaldeston

I've been hanging around here for what seems like an eternity so my list goes way past five, and would probably look different next week, but there are some constants. In no particular order...

1) Emma from Splosh (Juicy Pairs etc): just an absolute stunner
2) Liz from Mostwam: all the right curves in all the right places...
3) Bri from the bakery: very sexy, very funny (often without trying!) and endearingly warm-hearted
4) Messy Jessie: yes, I know it ended badly but still a pocket rocket
5) Mrs Bee: hoping she's doing well and keeping everything crossed for her

2/5/252/5/25

VegasWam

Las Vegas

Jayce
Larzstord
Messygirl Lexi
Toshia from SlapstickStuff
Paris Kennedy

Honorable mentions:
Wednesday Harrington
Kacie James
Messy Mia

2/5/252/5/25