At first, she was a good girl and did everything I asked of her. But after about a year of shooting, we developed a playful power struggle. She would make demands, such as giving her a massage or a foot rub before we shot. During one shoot, I asked her to roll around in the mess, but she refused, unless I swallowed a mouthful of it. During her mud submerging shoot, she told me she pissed in the mud tub. I had no way of knowing if she was telling me the truth or not, she was just that mischievous. She said she would not do anymore shoots unless she was allowed to destroy me for MessygirlsRevenge.com. During her shoots, she liked to get me messy by flinging the mess my way between scenes. I did get my revenge from time to time. For example, the "Shut Your Pie Hole" shoot was my idea. In that one, I had her hands tied above her head and I told her to insult me, After each insult, I would pie crap out of her. Deep down, we both enjoyed it. Yes, we had that kind director/model relationship. I enjoyed every minute of it.

OK,

This is fun.

Mrs Bee (even tho' she isn't a classic MG, more a collaboration, she was totally hot in the handful of scenes she did, esp in the substances we never really tried, such as gold paint and mud).

New Amy (cuz d'uh).

Justine (dunno if I bought that she was a wammer herself, but she definitely seemed to enjoy herself and moved quickly from timid to projecting confidence).

Vicky (for my taste and preferences, when London looked her best).

Connie (attractive, loved the bush...maybe more special cuz she was a one and done?)

My choice...

1-Mrs Bee
2-Lane
3-Angela
4-Penelope
5-Hannah

1. Nicole - Has to be one of my all time favorites!! Nicole definitely has that girl-next-door look, and I love the story that she didn't know she was getting messy but was totally up for trying it, and it shows how much she genuinely enjoyed it by the end!! The fact that she wanted to completely cover herself in the creamy pie and cake batter afterwards and then roll around in all that mess, posing and flirting with the camera is incredible!! Nicole covered head to toe in all that thick, creamy, and gooey pie mess yet we could still see her face and sexy smile while she teases us and the camera with the innocently flirty and naughty looks is incredible!!

2. Justine - The fact that Justine enjoyed getting messy even before becoming a Messygirl is awesome!! She genuinely is that pretty girl-next-door that has a playful naughty side with getting messy. Her pure excitement and enjoyment from getting as messy as possible is very obvious and amazing. Her extreme WAM full coverage scenes are incredible, being so eager to experiment with getting this messy so early on especially marshmallow fluff and corn syrup. I love scenes where the girl is so excited and into getting messy and just can't get enough of it, rolling around in all the mess and just getting lost in the pleasure and enjoyment!!

3. Fae - Fae's JustPieMe scene is one of the reasons that got me so into WAM!! The concept is incredible but so simple: innocently sexy girl in a bikini, splatter her pretty face with a dozen creamy pies while she laughs and giggles, enjoying the entire experience, and playfully rubbing all the pie mess and cream over her body after she realizes how much she truly enjoys getting all messy!!

4. New Amy - Don't really need to say much here!! Amy has that innocent face and flirty naughty smile when clean, and she becomes sexy and sensual when covered in mess!! Every scene she is in, it clearly shows how much she absolutely loves getting messy and how exciting it is for her to be completely covered in all kinds of mess!!

5. Deni - Deni definitely has that cute and pretty, girl-next-door look. What really got me about her is that look and smile of nervous apprehension and excitement!! From being nervous at the start to taking off her clothes halfway through then playing on the floor rubbing the mess over her body with a naughty and playful smile is incredible. The transformation from innocent and shy to sensual and excited shows is great!!

I didn't include Laurel from JustPieMe since she didn't become a full Messygirl, but she would have made the Top 5. Pretty face and a great smile with a really sweet and innocent look!! Looks fantastic splattered in all that pie cream and mess and looks like she had a great time!!

I was just wondering, did you stay in contact with Fae, Deni, or Nicole after their Messygirl scenes? I know this isn't something Nicole expected to do, but is there a chance to see any of these three in future Messygirl scenes? And it seems like Laurel's JustPieMe scene was a once-off a long time ago but would love to see her again too!!

Deni was an absolute cutie pie - like Penelope and Amber, definitely my type. And I think your description is pretty on the money. But sadly her one-time appearance keeps her from my list. I really wish Vika could've talked her into another video. Also, I remember Vika getting a little more touchy than I'm used to - especially on Deni's butt. Can't say I blame her tho...

Leah
Leah
Leah
Leah
Leah

*1. Mrs. Bee - with an asterisk because - as Bigshipper himself said - she's more of a collaboration than a true Messygirl, but it's STILL Mrs. Bee so I can't just NOT put her on the list, and since she's on the list I can't NOT put her on the top

1. Allison - no idea what her story was but she always seemed more like a college girl making some money on the side than a seasoned fetish model, and I've always loved the classic girl next door. But she also seemed to enjoy getting messy, even if it didn't necessarily turn her on. Always wished she'd make a return.

2. Vivian - she's a beautiful Asian woman and I'm me.

3. Lexi - took some of the best slimings ever throughout the years, and probably the most slime-first scenes of any Messygirl (my thing). For that she will always be the Messygirl "Moose" in my eyes (only gorgeous). Loved her open mouth reactions to those early Messygirl green cake batter deluges...would love to see it make a comeback.

4. Kellie the Australian - I know she was a one-and-done but that first pie hit was perfection and she is an absolute hammer.

5. Liz - which is weird because her looks run counter to everything I find attractive in a woman, but I'm a slime fan and she took some epic slimings over the years, and really seemed to enjoy it as well. Had a great 'resigned' reaction once the slime started pouring, which I love (I'm especially thinking of the quiz show scene with Lexi where she took an awesome yellow cake batter sliming while doing the old "hands out, nodding in acceptance" reaction...love it).

Always hard to put these lists together because there's always some Honorable Mentions. Might almost be worth a follow-up thread just for those.

For me (in no order):

Amy. Loves the camera and the camera really loves her.
Katie. Just so girl-next-door sexy.
Lexi. Impossibly cute.
Liz. Sultry, sexy, whatever it is, she's got it.
VIcky. Dangerous curves ahead!