Unnatural colored pies are a no from me. Not really a fan of shaving cream either.

Ideal pie would be whipped cream or cool whip on top, vanilla or chocolate pudding-ish filling, and a non-graham cracker crust. I like to eat graham cracker crusts, but when they smash on impact it kind of reminds me of sand?

I've put way too much thought into this.

The forum has spoken.

I prefer shaving cream, here are mine

Shaving foam pies on paper plates. Big thick ones. Great for sitting on and for pie sandwiches.