Hey guys!

Original Amy is returning to Messygirl. Could an Amy vs Amy messy battle be in the works? Stay tuned.

So down for an Amy / Amy mud wrestle.

Speaking of redheads, you should bring back Tammy, too. She hot!

"Crisis of Two Amys"

Who will win?

The audience!

o/
That's an awesome news!

I would love to see a messy battle between the Amys.

A match to know who is the best "Amy Messygirl" by doing practical tests like: best self-pieing, best head dunking, best messy shampoo, best pie sandwich...
Of course, they will have to demonstrate it on each other!

Damn, that would be a dream scenario!

Losing that one would really suck. Imagine if you were only the second-best Messygirl Amy!

Can't wait to see this!!! Amy is always amazing in everything she does at MessyGirl!!

Will she be doing customs

I have always had a thing for girls named Amy.
I could only hope for an Amy vs Amy mud wrestling match. All to find out who is the real messygirl Amy. (a comedic side of identity theft)

Seconding the muddy Amy-off!

I'm all for either an 'Amything Goes' mudwrestling match, or full-on muddy trib/sexfight.
Or black grease.......

Please have another muddy match exactly like the last one you had nothing needs to change the winner gets to keep the name Amy

Yes, she will be doing customs. Feel free to contact us for more info.

Best WAM news in ages...!

I loved classic Amy first time round and I also love new Amy...

Hmmm.

Can you love two Amys or is that considered cheating..?

And yes, they have to meet. They just have to.

What a great surprise!!!

amy vs amy staying clean vs loosing hair and getting destroyed in mess

Amy vs Amy a pie bake sale.

I second!
Both Amy-ies are so freaking hot!!!

That is great to see Amy coming back?!! Any chance of seeing any others like Katie or Sara?

OMG MG fantastic - can't wait for this

sure. take my money.

If Lane comes back, I'll go over there and partly fund a 100 pie shoot where Lane gets pied by me and MrMG

Wow! Both Amy's are so cute and so hot, yet totally in different ways!

I always enjoyed seeing "original Amy"! She was awesome!

But "new Amy" has stolen my heart!

Now, "new Amy" has been pretty brutal to her partners-in-wam! Is "original Amy" like that? She just seems like such a sweetheart!

Seeing the two of them together, with their different looks, and their different styles will be amazing!

Maybe have them each do a "CIAR" and see who the best/nastiest waitress is!

Norman

This is amazing! Can we please finally come together and group fund a Amy vs Amy piefight spectacular?! I'll write I and be the first funder, who is with me?!

Second this. Original Amy was very cute and sweet, while current Amy can't keep her hands off herself when she gets messy and isn't much more successful in keeping her hands off other people, either...

So, how about a "Good Girl v Bad Girl" scene? Would be fascinating to see whether or not current, "bad girl" Amy is able to keep her hands off original, "good girl" Amy as the scene progresses... :devil:

Both MG and Mr MG have pointed out that Lexi is now married and leading a spiritual life.

There needs to be a FAQ section on the Messygirl web site.