Hello everyone! Hope you're doing well and an early Happy New Years!

I was curious about what everyone's favourite types of pies were, whether that be whipped cream, shaving cream, real pies (if so which ones), butter cream etc. Any favourite fillings or combinations of different creams and fillings?

Let me know because I'm very interested in what everyone prefers. I'm also looking for ideas and new things to try come my next session!

I am quite partial to the classic, cream and custard combination myself, what about yourselves?

For me i'm quite into just a plain and boring whipped cream but when done correctly it absolutely is hard to beat, along with the classic shaving foam pie also.

What can I say... I'm not the most adventurous when it comes to pies.

I like the classic shaving cream pie. Simply put, it's what works for me.

I'm an old Amateur Pies/Pie Fight Girls/Neil Edwards fan, so all of the pies I use tend to be like his:

1. baked frozen pie crust
2. some sort of pudding filling
3. topped with cool whip (usually with food coloring mixed in)
4. thrown with extreme accuracy (ideally)

Feel free to look at my profile for some pictures of examples.

I am shaving cream all the way!

Materials are reasonably cheap (foam and pie tins or paper plates), you can make huge pies, the mess piles up in a way that I really like, & it washes away easily with water and doesn't leave lingering smells!

I also go for the sensitive skin varieties or ones that contain aloe to combat any issues with it stinging or overly drying my skin.

My favorite type of pie is made of cool whip. It sticks well, makes great visuals and feels great on your body.

Yeah, that's a fair. Stick to the classics and you can't go too wrong. To be fair I think it's quite hard to go wrong at all really

It's hard to beat for sure, for how cheap, easy and fun it is I'm not surprised why its one of the most popular choices and im sure it works for a heck of a lot of people indeed to put it lightly

Those definitely look very enticing and yummy.

I'm sure that the effect after being hit with one looked amazing and the feeling of the weight of it as it cascades all over, even better.

I see why it is such a popular choice. A lot of upsides with very little downsides, especially if you want a quick, fun pieing with an easy clean-up afterwards.

Do you venture beyond shaving cream at all?

Cool whip is great! I really like the texture of it, would you add anything else? Or do you prefer just cool whip on its own?

I have been creating my own pies for a while now due to the lack of good pies available in the uk, so wish we got coolwhip

Your pies are awesome man. You should publish the recipe, everyone should be using that stuff.

It's all about the feel and taste of a fruit pie with a thick layer of whipped topping on the top for me. That's my first place, followed by chocolate or merengue pie. While non-dairy whipped topping doesn't feel better than the other, it sure smells less later if it gets in your nose and ears.

Pudding, mallow, caramel,chocolate,fruit filling, and overflowing.

I like decorated on top... So I need to see them before the impact...

I like filled with fruit... Blueberry specially... The contrast of colors is really nice...

And the base of it, marshmallow... The slow dripping is just lovely!!

And use different colors for every pie...

Real crust pies filled with whipped cream or thick Greek yogurt and topped with custard or chocolate sauce. Feels great when smashed into my face.

Thank you I have published a few of my recipes

I know they get a lot of hate on here, but one of my absolute favourite types of pie is just the classic 'shaving cream on paper plate' pie. If good quality shaving cream is used, and the pie is delivered with good technique then the coverage from them is incredible. I love the look, the texture and how easy it is for a model to be given a thorough pieing!

I also really like the more 'American' shaving cream pies where they're in a tin with a crust lining. Some of my favourite ever scenes use these pies as it's super easy to get fantastic coverage just by using a firm splat.

And finally, I also really like the traditional 'custard pies'. These were the type of pie typically seen on UK TV when I was growing up. They were usually whipped cream with a bit of custard on more of a 'flan' base. They always gave great coverage from a firm splat! I also just like the phrase 'custard pie'- very suggestive!

Mostwam cream pie over here, please!

What ever is splattered on myself or my wife lol but seriously pudding or batter topped with whipped cream, frosting or marshmallow cream or fluff.

I'm gonna try pumpkin tomorrow.

I've done syrup pies.

These were perfect. $3. Perfect face size. Exact amount of pie filling, cream topping, crust coverage. OPs know.

I've always liked Cool whip on its own. I am going to try adding sprinkles the next time I get pied.

Definitely shaving foam. Great coverage and easy to clean up. Would love to try a Cool Whip pie but it's not available in the UK. Next best thing over here would be to try Dream Topping. Mighy give that a try this year

Women_in_comedy Instagram page simply uses shaving cream in a graham cracker crust pie shell and the results are spectacular!

Depends. If I have time, I make my own, with a recipe I have. It's mostly just powdered sugar and water, but it's great.

If I'm in a hurry, I just use shaving cream, mixed with a small amount of water to make it more gooey and smooth.

I'd be interested to see that in action.

Last month I used applesauce, topped with whip cream and chocolate syrup...i prefer whip cream over shaving cream pies but my wife like shaving cream pies, nothing dairy because of the smell. I like fill mine with chocolate pudding or applesauce and eggs then dust with flour to create a more sticky pie

The ones here are applesauce with whip cream and chocolate

Nothing but store bought for me because I like the way they look (see profile pic) and how naughty it feels to ruin them. Prettier the better.

I've tried so many at this point. Marie Callender's chocolate satin and banana cream are my faves. Safeway makes amazing pies as well but they're so expensive. Edwards deserves a big shoutout as well. Just avoid the ones with too many solid toppings on top, or remove them first.

Of course, all frozen pies must be thawed fully per box directions.