I vote for shock but my favourite is a combination of various reactions the shocked/humiliation reaction at first later disgust and finally fun and enjoyment

When I came out of the pie closet in the early nineties after seeing Pie Face Mike on Jenny Jones, my girlfriend at that time shared everything with her mother. Her mother wanted to pie me. I, of course, wouldn't let her pie me in the face because of what happens to me when I get pied. Long story short, I guess one day the Stars just aligned and I decided to let her hit me with a pie, 12 cream pies to be exact. When she smashed the first cream pie in my face I orgasmed and came in my pants. She was shocked and amazed for a few moments asking her daughter, "Did he just have what I think he had?!!"
My girlfriend replied, "Yes...mom...DUH!! I thought you knew this was what was going to happen. Why do you think he likes me to throw cream pies in his face when he dresses up in his rubber and vinyl outfits!"
Her mother laughed and got a Sly smirk on her face and proceeded to hit me with the 11 other banana cream pies.

Thats so funny! Thanks for sharing.

Great question!! I've found that I often either scream out in shock as something horrible splats on my head and covers my face! Or as a few people have said in this thread my favourite is laughing, I sometimes laugh at just the sheer joy, sillyness and pleasure of Sploshing! It evokes so many feelings and senses. I just love being on the receiving end of a good amount straight over the head!!!
I do love the surprise factor of not knowing what's being poured over me though, that is such a thrill when being the recipient of something warm, cold, lumpy, smooth, smelly, silky, thick, runny that reaction can't be faked by a model! When it first hits your head with a huge SPLAT!!
Brooke xx

Without doubt, MewMew is the queen of expressions, never uses the same one twice, and every one is awesome/sexy/hilarious :')

If it has to do with TV or movies, I like a lot of different expressions it depends on the scene. One of my favorites is a Three Stooges short where Moe takes a cake out of a lady's hands and nails her in the face with it. The coverage is perfect. You can't see her facial expression but she just stands there and brings her hands up to her face without wiping her face off and she begins to cry. The scene is on YouTube if anybody wants to look it up. At the moment I don't remember the specific details or the actress's name but it should be easy to find.
There is also a basic instinct pie parody by WAMTEC/MK models, that I find incredibly sexy.
I'm not a big fan of videos where the person getting pied or messy is laughing and having total fun with it like it's a lark.
Don't get me wrong there is nothing wrong with that. It is great to see people having fun doing something that they like doing.
But for me, getting a cream pie in the face is so sexual and erotic, it's not a laughing matter, it's extremely intense. It's an orgasm for me, PIEGASM, if you will. With that point being made, how many people do you know have sex with their partner of choice and laugh and titter uncontrollably as they have a orgasm doing straight sex.
My profile here on UMD is true...I truly orgasm from a Cream Pie in my face.
So aside from the movies and TV, I love watching all of you "regular" folk posting what gets you off. The CREAMERY lady, posting pictures recently of her in a baby blue leather outfit and caking herself and masturbating got me so hot and worked up I had to pie myself. I believe I posted the pictures under "cherry red vinyl and see-through pink".
The honesty of how sexual it is for some of us really gets me off more than the "I like doing this just for a lark and it's a turn-on" part of our community.
I'll wind this post up by saying God bless Bill Shipton and what used to be SPLOSH magazine. I had correspondence with Bill and Haley over the years and they were both beautiful people. I think I might be partially responsible for getting Haley to come out and get pied in the magazine for the first time wearing a latex rubber catsuit. Bless her heart she never thought she was attractive enough!!!!
Can you believe that?
I think I am partially responsible also for the section on the SPLOSH website called,"JUST BECAUSE IT'S SHINY DOESN'T MEAN IT HAS TO BE CLEAN".
I've got some magazines where Bill posted my letters, which is totally cool by the way, and him razzing me for what I wrote. It was all in good fun, but we both tried to take the piss out of each other on occasion so to speak.
I'll see what I can do to scan those magazines and post the pictures soon.

Well it looks like it will be killer. I'm sure I will buy it as soon as it comes out. Kate really makes a top notch victim.

Okay, the pie/cake in the face scene on The Three stooges short is with the actress Greta Thyssen. Type her name in the search with" pie in the face".
There is actually two shorts. One with the cake and one where she gets hit with a pie.

Absolutely agree, while I love them all, the reluctant acceptance is also my favorite!

My favorite reaction is shock/surprised. I enjoy watching women getting messy, but when they don't see it coming, it only adds to the turn on.

Wow! What an amazing turnout in this poll. I think the winner is clear - shock! I had a fewling this was the most desirable reaction but i wanted to make sure. I am also a hige fan of the victem progressing into a state of acceptance or as Kate says "midaswell".