You know, the girl(s) is hotter than hell, the mess, the direction, the acting, ...........everything.

Even in the vids I love, there is always something lacking.

Thanks! I like the ambition of that scene, but the execution is... Lacking.

Although that said, I was disappointed in the "Messy Movies" scene too. I guess I was expecting... More?

There's never gonna be a consensus on this forum. Far too many specific tastes and niches.

Nope. There'll never be a perfect scene. I mean, even a great scene is just a reasonable approximation of something you'd want to participate in (or watch live).

Somebody invent the holodeck, and then we'll talk about perfect scenes.

"At The Messy Movies" was my favorite for a long time. Sadly I don't own it anymore. Lenny's vid "KISSES ALA KREME" is perfect in my opinion.

How can you have a favorite scene and not have a copy of it? That's, like, tragic.

Don't get married, kids! All your coveted VHS tapes (from a bygone era) and DVDs may disappear. Oh, the humanity! At least video downloads now-a-days are easier to hide.

Truer words. Sorry you had to find out the hard way, dude!

I guess with so many different tastes this is just like asking what's your favourite scene...?

Personally I love Camilla and the naughty cakes, from Messy Angel. Whilst it is not 'perfect', the girl looks exactly my 'type', it's dedicated to cake sitting, and her sounds are wonderful to listen to as she squashes the cakes. I like it enough to keep a copy on my phone.

Absolutely check out jayce and Ariel in white jeans having a food fight they are fantastic

There is always something that can be improved on. The perfect scene is a kind of holy grail we can all chase but never quite reach.

And of course it'll be wildly different for different people, and one person's perfect scene will be someone else's major disappointment.

I have the "At the Messy Movies" scene on DVD along with the 12 girl pie fight and a few other scenes that came out on a brief Messy Fun's Greatest Pie Hits DVD; The Tawnie/Frenchie slip scene is pretty excellent too. In my opinion, my fellow Texan Rob Blaine was the greatest; Rich is the next closest thing. If he would ever go R and use stockings I'd be his greatest customer and would buy all that stuff. That being said, the greatest pie scene has to be the 12 girl pie fight. Excellent build up, great pies, hot girls including all of Blaine's A list.

There was one from Download Dreams with a woman in leather pants and leather jacket in an incredible mud pit (quarry?) that, to me, was as close to perfect as I could ever imagine.

I'm sure the "perfect" scene must be at least free right.

Refresh my memory, at the end of any of the allegedly perfect scenes mentioned above, do I come in at the end and fuck the messy girls until they can't stand up? No? Because if not, then I'm afraid they're not perfect.

My "perfect" scene was WTF Download's "Heather Engulfed".

Classy and well executed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_JN3LbZ4po

There was that one, but at the end the girl called you "Dorothy" instead of "Bea," so it ruined the entire thing for me. :-S