Texas bbw lover2 said: I would love to see Katey Sagal pied as Peggy Bundy, circa 1990 or so.

SlowBurn said: I think Maisie Williams would be an amazing pie target. Who wouldn't love to see her get thoroughly creamed?

adecourv said: For me, it's not just celebs I find attractive, I'd also pick women who would have fun reactions:
Zooey Deschanel, Jennifer Lawrence (as Mystique or out of costume - it's a free country), Amy Adams, Alexandra Daddario and Anna Paquin
I'd also like to see Margot Robbie, but more specifically as Harley Quinn. Getting into details, I feel curvy women like Kat Dennings and Hayley Atwell would look good in mud and/or chocolate
And for a hot take, back when Karen Gillan and Natalie Portman had buzzcuts, I'd love to see them recreate that Gwen Elise video where they'd get demolished in pies. Come to think of it, bald Karen or Natalie getting slimed would be priceless too.

cfoster_812 said: Taraji P. Henson (Cookie Lyon) from "Empire" as well as Grace Byers (Anika Calhoun) from "Empire".