Just watched a video of a guy getting pied by a girl at what appears to be a college fundraiser event. The body language of both the girl doing the pieing and the guy taking it added something to the video for me. She seemed excited to smear the pie in his face. He was squirming a bit as she pied him, possibly out of nervousness or humiliation. Either way, she pied him in the face like a pro, and he did just as good of a job taking it. I find that it's the small details that can really elevate a pie in the face to the next level.
100%. It's hard for those of us on here that get pied a lot, because you really can't replicate all that stuff from your first time: the anticipation, the nervousness, the weird gooey sensation once it hits you. I think that's what makes all the amateur pieings and videos with first-time models so appealing. I just don't think someone's reaction will get any better than when they lose their pie virginity.
First, thanks to SplatterMyFace for finding those vids and posting them. Body and facial language adds so much to a good pieing. Its essential. Which is why i disagree with Hooliham. If someone is getting pied "a lot" and taking the time to videotape it, then is it really all that hard to do some acting and add expression?