Gone said: messiest single pie: here's one that featured more than 100 cans of shaving cream and gallon after gallon of vanilla pudding at the bottom.

66Pies said: I made a giant pie using 8 full cans of shaving cream

simplepies99 said: Good topic. I brought it up a few years ago. Here is the link:

https://umd.net/forums/one-pie-success

Filbert McFloop said: Here is one of mine. One pie, which is normally my preference.

simplepies99 said: Good topic. I brought it up a few years ago. Here is the link:

https://umd.net/forums/one-pie-success

wamajama said: Well, it all depends on how you define 'messy' (viz a viz 'pie)...and keep in mind that most all pies in the face are, by definition, 'messy'....my take on it is a combination of pie quality, impact, and aftermath.

Here's Tabitha's first pie as an example of what I call a 'messy pie'

messyrob1980 said: So looking at the poll it seems people love single pies that make masses of mess. Trying to think what the messiest single pie has been. I was thinking this one features almost gone and cream probably over an inch thick. But then I thought back to the pie that Lilynextdoor took testing my recipes and think it's probably that one.

What has been the messiest single pie you have seen, please feel free to share pics if you have them

Hmmm maybe it's time to reopen the lab and start looking for willing testers in the quest for the messiest single pie.