Next Time said: If I remember right, I think Carmen was a journalist doing it as research for a magazine article.
Now you say it I think you might be right. I vaguely remember the video description mentioning she came across the site when writing something, but can't check as the video has been removed from GungeGirls.
I remember seeing Carmen on Channel 4 talking heads shows in 2000's (remember them?). I have a memory of her being a journalist and doing the shoot to write an article about it, don't know how accurate my memory is.
Would have been around the same sort of time as an article in Bizarre magazine that featured a fair amount of noise/kowalski models and the obligatory Bill Shipton interview.
Ah that's intriguing, must be interesting to see someone who was involved in a WAM shoot outside of that sort of setting. Think you're right about the journalist angle as Next Time was saying just above you in the thread.
Is that article you mention available to read online anywhere, would be curious to see it?
hg_04 said: I remember seeing Carmen on Channel 4 talking heads shows in 2000's (remember them?). I have a memory of her being a journalist and doing the shoot to write an article about it, don't know how accurate my memory is.
Would have been around the same sort of time as an article in Bizarre magazine that featured a fair amount of noise/kowalski models and the obligatory Bill Shipton interview.
Ah that's intriguing, must be interesting to see someone who was involved in a WAM shoot outside of that sort of setting. Think you're right about the journalist angle as Next Time was saying just above you in the thread.
Is that article you mention available to read online anywhere, would be curious to see it?
I've just tried looking and can't find it. It would have been around 2005 to 2006. Decadent Doll (is she still around here?) sent in some photos into their 'reader's wives' section (they were doing it 'ironically', I think. It was the noughties after all ), and in the next issue they had a full article on sploshing. Miss T was in it I think, images of Fi Stevens and Dominique and others. It was totally that magazine's sort of thing and they had real fun it with. I'll carry on looking because I want to see it again too.
EDIT: it's issue 113 from August 2006. Can find the cover but none of the content.
JazzTalker said: Mine would be Lily from PiedPinups or Erin from Slapstickstuff vol 131. They did multiple scenes (2 and 3 each) but presumably over only one day of shooting, so to me it's really like one volume of video.
jacktatum32 said: If we're counting one volume, then I'm always bummed Sydney from Slapstickstuff never came back. So cute and so enthusiastic, I think a close minded boyfriend put the kibosh on it.
Great picks. Erin was super fun, and I was a bit bummed as she was friends with Kristin (from SS101 and others) so I could've used her earlier, in theory. Or the two of them together. Anyway, she moved to Vegas, and was gonna come back & shoot, but there was an "incident" at the club she worked at and she wound up in the hospital! I won't get any details, but her modeling career effectively ended there, so bad all around. (She got married to a rich guy and moved to the middle of the country later, which is what a lot of SOuthern girls do!)
Sydney.... SIGH. She could've been a great model for years. She loved getting messy. She would've done it for free. Sadly, she immediately started dating a BF (now husband) who needed to "control" his partner. (Another Southern thing.) That was the end of her modeling career forever.
I will say, "one video" feels very limiting. I'm not randomly pieing some girl on the street or throwing up a Craiglist ad to bring in a one-and-done for quick cash. All of my "one and dones" were legit shoots and legit models and we often shot many scenes that day. But most models aren't "lifers," especially if they're doing it part-time, so a lot had epic single shoots but never came back. Feel free to talk about those! If all their scenes were released on a single "volume," that should count.
I was daydreaming about this thread during a tedious work trip today and the thought occurs that hg_04's original post is a good steer, as well as SlapstickStuff, there really were a few good one and dones at Gungegirls, or at least where only a couple of scenes (but likely shot in a day or quick succession?).
Amy's attempt at the bikini slime challenge was a masterpiece. Later F1 pitlane model (if I remember right? I may be wrong, correct me if so) Von definitely did not like beans, although she also did a custard scene. Nikki was great at reactions, and the multiply-sploshed Jade's mate Rosie definitely got what Custard Corner was about (note that cheeky pointing finger! ).
PS- I wasn't a fan of Custard Corner at the time. Obviously I was a fool.
I've just tried looking and can't find it. It would have been around 2005 to 2006. Decadent Doll (is she still around here?) sent in some photos into their 'reader's wives' section (they were doing it 'ironically', I think. It was the noughties after all ), and in the next issue they had a full article on sploshing. Miss T was in it I think, images of Fi Stevens and Dominique and others. It was totally that magazine's sort of thing and they had real fun it with. I'll carry on looking because I want to see it again too.
EDIT: it's issue 113 from August 2006. Can find the cover but none of the content.
messwriter said: I was daydreaming about this thread during a tedious work trip today and the thought occurs that hg_04's original post is a good steer, as well as SlapstickStuff, there really were a few good one and dones at Gungegirls, or at least where only a couple of scenes (but likely shot in a day or quick succession?).
Amy's attempt at the bikini slime challenge was a masterpiece. Later F1 pitlane model (if I remember right? I may be wrong, correct me if so) Von definitely did not like beans, although she also did a custard scene. Nikki was great at reactions, and the multiply-sploshed Jade's mate Rosie definitely got what Custard Corner was about.
PS- I wasn't a fan of Custard Corner at the time. Obviously I was a fool.
Nikki's video is definitely a good shout, certainly was a great duo with Fifi in her interactions. The initial shock to the yellow gunge is great fun.
It was never even released, but the teases for her one and only video looked awesome.
Another unreleased WTFdownloads video that would've been an all-timer for me as a fan of messy redheads, Alexa . As far as I know, there wasn't even a trailer released so these teaser shots are all there is
And yet another from the WTFdownloads vaults... Anne-Louise who shot at least 3 scenes that I don't think were ever released.
WTF was selling upscaled versions of some of their old videos a couple of years ago, but that store no longer appers to be open. If you're still out there, WTF, know that you are missed! You must be sitting on an absolute goldmine of unreleased content!
It was never even released, but the teases for her one and only video looked awesome.
Another unreleased WTFdownloads video that would've been an all-timer for me as a fan of messy redheads, Alexa . As far as I know, there wasn't even a trailer released so these teaser shots are all there is
And yet another from the WTFdownloads vaults... Anne-Louise who shot at least 3 scenes that I don't think were ever released.
WTF was selling upscaled versions of some of their old videos a couple of years ago, but that store no longer appers to be open. If you're still out there, WTF, know that you are missed! You must be sitting on an absolute goldmine of unreleased content!
@wtfdownloads He rebranded as www.piefight.com but I don't think anything came of it - he still pops up here now and then, so you never know...
My favorite was Messygirl "Valerie". This goes waaaaaay back to 2009. She was NOT into it at first and I thought I had made a mistake buying the video, but every so slowly she gets more and more into it and eventually she transforms into a beautiful mud coated goddess. (Beautiful before too, but you all know what I'm saying). One thing I loved was she kept checking herself out and she was a perfectionist about it too, she wanted to be covered everywhere and have it look perfect.
1/14/26, 11:39am: 4 images removed after admin review
I'm gonna have to go with Freshie. she shot a couple scenes with SlapstickBabes (one getting messy, two dishing out pies to Scarlet). something about her just ticked all the boxes for me.
that said, special mention to all the one-and-done models who shot with Hot Mess Pies. Some quality gals there and some great scenes.
QuicksilverCooler said: My favourites are a two-fer's from Slapstickstuff
139 with Stacy and Sam (wish Sam got a few more pies, the few hits were amazing)
And 42 with Kara with her sister (?)
God damn those were fantastic.
SS139: Stacy wasn't really that into it, and the volume didn't sell well, so I let that be a one-and-done. Her friend Sam was fun tho! She just tagged along and decided to get pied in the moment. What a gal! I'm not even sure she asked to get paid?!?
SS42: The strawberry blonde was just Kara's friend Shannon, also a model. Tagged along to basically pie Kara, then decided to participate in that one epic scene. (For a long time it was THE biggest seller in SS history!) Kara *also* brought her sister along, and she's the one who briefly throws pies at her in a couple scenes. (Her aim was quite bad, but I admire the enthusiasm!)
I miss those days. The last era of true girls-next-door being genuinely excited to do messy shoots.
QuicksilverCooler said: My favourites are a two-fer's from Slapstickstuff
139 with Stacy and Sam (wish Sam got a few more pies, the few hits were amazing)
And 42 with Kara with her sister (?)
God damn those were fantastic.
SS139: Stacy wasn't really that into it, and the volume didn't sell well, so I let that be a one-and-done. Her friend Sam was fun tho! She just tagged along and decided to get pied in the moment. What a gal! I'm not even sure she asked to get paid?!?
SS42: The strawberry blonde was just Kara's friend Shannon, also a model. Tagged along to basically pie Kara, then decided to participate in that one epic scene. (For a long time it was THE biggest seller in SS history!) Kara *also* brought her sister along, and she's the one who briefly throws pies at her in a couple scenes. (Her aim was quite bad, but I admire the enthusiasm!)
I miss those days. The last era of true girls-next-door being genuinely excited to do messy shoots.
That's a bummer (though I guess not exactly shocking) that she wasn't that into it. Still, it remains one of my all-time fav's.
And re: volume 42, ahh gotcha - I was close! I do remember reading something for maybe an anniversary or such that mentioned that particular scene being a huge hit.
Do you know what takes the top spot these days? I would have to guess something with Carrie or Breanna.
That's a bummer (though I guess not exactly shocking) that she wasn't that into it. Still, it remains one of my all-time fav's.
And re: volume 42, ahh gotcha - I was close! I do remember reading something for maybe an anniversary or such that mentioned that particular scene being a huge hit.
Do you know what takes the top spot these days? I would have to guess something with Carrie or Breanna.
I think Stacy was actually more "flat" than anything else. I like models with big personalities, and she wasn't really that, so I didn't book her again. It's happened before. Angela from SS60 was similarly flat, but she went on to shoot a ton with another producer. So she was clearly fine with getting messy, but her default always seemed to be "bored" or "let's get this over with," and those weren't the models I wanted to shoot repeatedly.
So I just looked.... The SS42 scene is STILL the #1 seller. (Like Thriller, it came from a different era and those sales will never be replicated now!) What's interesting is that #2 is now.... Toshia and the Wardrobe Malfunction. Yep, her 1st ever sliming just keeps on selling! And #3 is my first ever two-girl scene from SS14, starring Deana & her roommate.... Shot in her kitchen! Amazing.
Of the more "recent" HD scenes, Breana probably has the best sales overall.... But because she shot so many clips, her sales are spread out. Same with Carrie. (Although all her SS125/SS116/SS163 scenes are big sellers.) The two biggest HD scenes, however, both belong to.... Kylie! Yep, her first two topless scenes (coincidentally, the first two SS scenes with actual nudity) sold like gangbusters, and continue to sell well even now.... (Plus they're priced higher than the SS42 and Toshia clips, so Kylie has probably brought in more profit overall.... Haha....)
pieboy said: I'll add another SlapstickStuff model. Again, not strictly a single scene gal but a single volume; Trista from SS38.
She was cute, funny, and really got it. Still one of the great "multiple pies? What's that?" Skits.
A couple other SS girls in addition to SS131 (who I also adore) are:
- SS126 - so cute, great hair and body - SS146 - cute, funny, beautiful
Aw, I always liked Trista. We stayed in touch for years after on Facebook (remember Facebook?!?). She only modeled briefly, so that's why she never came back, which is too bad.... She was a genuinely great person IRL and I wish she'd shot longer.
As for SS126 Katy..... Yeah, you and every other customer wish she'd returned too! I've told this story before, but the moment I was sitting in a restaurant and happened to catch an ad for this new movie "Ride Along" starring Kevin Hart and Ice Cube.... and the trailer ended with "my" Katy towering over Kevin Hart in 6-inch heels as he cracked a joke about her height..... My first thought was, "Yep, she's not coming back...."
SS146 Alex.... Sigh. I tried for YEARS with her. She always seemed amicable to the idea of returning but it never quite happened. She eventually got a big-time job managing a nightclub in TX, so good for her. She clearly doesn't need pie-shoot money anymore! (She's still super cute too.)
So I just looked.... The SS42 scene is STILL the #1 seller. (Like Thriller, it came from a different era and those sales will never be replicated now!) What's interesting is that #2 is now.... Toshia and the Wardrobe Malfunction. Yep, her 1st ever sliming just keeps on selling! And #3 is my first ever two-girl scene from SS14, starring Deana & her roommate.... Shot in her kitchen! Amazing.
Of the more "recent" HD scenes, Breana probably has the best sales overall.... But because she shot so many clips, her sales are spread out. Same with Carrie. (Although all her SS125/SS116/SS163 scenes are big sellers.) The two biggest HD scenes, however, both belong to.... Kylie! Yep, her first two topless scenes (coincidentally, the first two SS scenes with actual nudity) sold like gangbusters, and continue to sell well even now.... (Plus they're priced higher than the SS42 and Toshia clips, so Kylie has probably brought in more profit overall.... Haha....)
That's fascinating! It's neat that 42 still takes the top spot, and mannnn I remember vol. 14! I thought Deanna's roommate was devastatingly gorgeous. She looks like she took it like a champ.
And like one of the above commenters, I also thought 126 was fantastic. She was amazing and got absolutely clobbered. It was only one volume, but what a volume it was!
Wait, so it turns out that the Ultimate Question of Life, the Universe, and Everything was actually 'Which SlapstickStuff volume is the highest seller of all time?'
Solid Hitchhiker's Guide reference.... Hope it didn't go over too many heads!
That's fascinating! It's neat that 42 still takes the top spot, and mannnn I remember vol. 14! I thought Deanna's roommate was devastatingly gorgeous. She looks like she took it like a champ.
And like one of the above commenters, I also thought 126 was fantastic. She was amazing and got absolutely clobbered. It was only one volume, but what a volume it was!
I've told this story too, but the only reason that SS14 even happened is because Casey (the roommate) accompanied Deana to her 1st solo shoot, which was SS11. And, famously, the shoot where Deana had NO idea she was getting pied and was quite surprised to see a bunch of pies sitting around. (Yes, I told her several times over the phone. Yes, she wasn't paying attention. And yes, any model today would immediately just call off the shoot and leave. Different era....)
Anyway, Casey had so much fun watching her friend unexpectedly get destroyed with pies (and throwing a few herself) that she happily suggested that they do one together. And that was the first SS 2-girl shoot!
Deana stuck around of course... But her and Casey had a falling out (it happens with college women) and she never returned for the various sequels. (Deana's friend Carrie, also a petite Southern blonde, is the one you seeing smashing D with pies and sometimes getting clobbered in SS25 and SS30.)
SlapstickStuff said: I've told this story too, but the only reason that SS14 even happened is because Casey (the roommate) accompanied Deana to her 1st solo shoot, which was SS11. And, famously, the shoot where Deana had NO idea she was getting pied and was quite surprised to see a bunch of pies sitting around.
...Rich, what the hell did she *think* was gonna happen? And how did she take the news?
That's fascinating! It's neat that 42 still takes the top spot, and mannnn I remember vol. 14! I thought Deanna's roommate was devastatingly gorgeous. She looks like she took it like a champ.
And like one of the above commenters, I also thought 126 was fantastic. She was amazing and got absolutely clobbered. It was only one volume, but what a volume it was!
I've told this story too, but the only reason that SS14 even happened is because Casey (the roommate) accompanied Deana to her 1st solo shoot, which was SS11. And, famously, the shoot where Deana had NO idea she was getting pied and was quite surprised to see a bunch of pies sitting around. (Yes, I told her several times over the phone. Yes, she wasn't paying attention. And yes, any model today would immediately just call off the shoot and leave. Different era....)
Anyway, Casey had so much fun watching her friend unexpectedly get destroyed with pies (and throwing a few herself) that she happily suggested that they do one together. And that was the first SS 2-girl shoot!
Deana stuck around of course... But her and Casey had a falling out (it happens with college women) and she never returned for the various sequels. (Deana's friend Carrie, also a petite Southern blonde, is the one you seeing smashing D with pies and sometimes getting clobbered in SS25 and SS30.)
You got me looking up who else was just one volume.
I was SHOCKED Heather was only in one. Partially because she was the face of your Youtube channel after the Breana vids were removed, and partially because I probably mistake her for Shauna sometimes haha.
I'm also shocked Angie only did one, she was mad cute and seemed like she was having a great time.
SlapstickStuff said: I've told this story too, but the only reason that SS14 even happened is because Casey (the roommate) accompanied Deana to her 1st solo shoot, which was SS11. And, famously, the shoot where Deana had NO idea she was getting pied and was quite surprised to see a bunch of pies sitting around.
...Rich, what the hell did she *think* was gonna happen? And how did she take the news?
I assume she thought it was a regular boring photo shoot?? (It's been 21 years, memory a bit foggy.)
I do remember her being quite surprised at all the pies, but not freaking out or anything.... Meanwhile Casey was CACKLING with laughter. I believe "Best day EVER!" was said a few times.
Truthfully, it could've easily gone sideways.... Best-case scenario was for Deana to come with a friend who thought this was hilarious and NEEDED to see it happen. Whatever cold feet she might've had, she couldn't back out with Casey there!
(FYI your pics all of Casey in the later scene that was NOT a surprise. Which is fine. But this is Deana in full "I might regret this" mode.)
jacktatum32 said: You got me looking up who else was just one volume.
I was SHOCKED Heather was only in one. Partially because she was the face of your Youtube channel after the Breana vids were removed, and partially because I probably mistake her for Shauna sometimes haha.
I'm also shocked Angie only did one, she was mad cute and seemed like she was having a great time.
Woo boy. Heather was truly crazy.... in a fun way? But also, I picked up a fifth of vodka for her before the shoot, and that bottle was GONE somewhere around Scene 2, so..... It was fun and wild and lightning in a bottle, but not something I would ever replicate for a future shoot. Also, Heather wasn't local and was basically transitioning to management. She tried to set me up with a gorgeous Latina in her roster, sadly that girl wasn't into pies. (I also wish I'd shot Zarah and Heather together back in the 2000s.... That would've been nuts. By the time I worked with Heather, Zarah was already a mom with a super-rich husband and totally done with pie shoots...)
Angie.... SIGH. We had the best time. She was tons of fun. But she'd just started dating a guy (now her husband) and he freaked out over the pie thing afterwards. That was the main reason she never came back. We stayed in touch for years, a few times she talked about wanting to do it but it would always come back to, "He won't let me." She's a new mom now. Good for her! One epic pie volume at least!
Venturing further into 'Favourite Slapstickstuff model who only did one shoot' territory, here. But there's two standout candidates for me. Slightly cheating in that they technically both did do more than one video, but it was all part of a 'one and done' shoot (to my knowledge).
1. SS119, Alicia and Riley. Admittedly I don't know which model is which, but the girl on the left with her hair down in the photos really caught my eye. Super, super cute and seemed to have a blast getting pied and slimed with her friend. She is also the spitting image of a girl I went to uni with- a girl I had a huge crush on, I might add!
2. SS144, Aliyah. Just drop dead gorgeous! Great figure, super curvy. A shame she only did one shoot!